Aquaponics- Choosing Pacu

Aquaponics- Choosing Pacu

Aquaponics with Pacu: Benefits and Challenges

Aquaponics—the integration of aquaculture (raising fish) and hydroponics (growing plants without soil)—has gained attention as a sustainable food production system. While species like tilapia and catfish are commonly used, pacu (genus Piaractus and Colossoma) are an increasingly interesting option for aquaponic growers seeking fast growth, hardiness, and high-quality protein. This article explores how pacu fit into aquaponic systems, along with the benefits and challenges of keeping them.

Why Choose Pacu for Aquaponics?

Pacu are South American freshwater fish closely related to piranhas, though they are generally peaceful and primarily herbivorous or omnivorous. Their adaptability and feeding habits make them suitable for aquaponic environments when properly managed.

Key Characteristics of Pacu

  • Fast growth rates under warm-water conditions

  • Omnivorous diet with a strong preference for plant-based foods

  • Hardy fish that tolerate a range of water conditions

  • High market and table value due to firm, mild-flavored flesh

Benefits of Using Pacu in Aquaponics

1. Efficient Nutrient Production

Pacu produce substantial waste relative to their feed intake. In aquaponics, this waste is converted by beneficial bacteria into nitrates, which plants readily absorb. This supports vigorous growth of leafy greens, herbs, and even fruiting crops.

2. Omnivorous, Plant-Friendly Diet

Unlike strictly carnivorous fish, pacu can thrive on feeds with high plant content. This can reduce reliance on expensive fishmeal-based feeds and align well with the plant-focused philosophy of aquaponics.

3. Rapid Growth and High Yield

Under optimal conditions, pacu can grow quickly, reaching harvest size faster than many traditional aquaponic fish. This makes them attractive for growers focused on protein production and system efficiency.

4. Hardiness and Disease Resistance

Pacu are generally robust and can tolerate fluctuations in water quality better than more sensitive species. This resilience can be especially valuable for beginners or in systems where conditions are not perfectly stable.

5. Dual-Purpose Value

In addition to being a food fish, pacu are sometimes valued for educational or demonstration systems due to their size, appearance, and interesting behavior.

Challenges of Keeping Pacu in Aquaponics

1. Large Adult Size

One of the biggest challenges with pacu is their size. Many species can grow well over 60 cm (2 feet) and become quite heavy. This requires:

  • Large fish tanks or ponds

  • Strong system infrastructure

  • Careful stocking density management

Small backyard systems may quickly become unsuitable as pacu mature.

2. High Oxygen Demand

Fast growth and large body mass mean pacu require well-oxygenated water. Insufficient aeration can lead to stress, reduced growth, or mortality. Reliable air pumps and backup systems are strongly recommended.

3. Warm Water Requirements

Pacu are tropical fish and perform best in water temperatures between 24–30°C (75–86°F). In cooler climates, maintaining these temperatures year-round can increase energy costs due to heating.

4. Strong Feeding Behavior

Pacu are enthusiastic feeders and have powerful jaws. This can lead to:

  • Damage to plumbing or tank components if poorly protected

  • Overfeeding if not carefully monitored

  • Increased solid waste load, requiring effective filtration

5. Regulatory and Availability Issues

In some regions, pacu are regulated due to concerns about invasive species. Permits may be required, or the species may be restricted entirely. Sourcing juvenile fish can also be more difficult compared to common aquaponic species.

Best Practices for Raising Pacu in Aquaponics

  • Design systems with future fish size in mind, not just juveniles

  • Use robust mechanical filtration to manage solid waste

  • Maintain consistent aeration and monitor dissolved oxygen

  • Feed a balanced diet with controlled portions

  • Check local regulations before purchasing or stocking pacu

Conclusion

Pacu can be an excellent but demanding choice for aquaponics. Their rapid growth, plant-friendly diet, and hardiness offer clear benefits, especially for large or commercial-scale systems. However, their size, oxygen needs, and warm-water requirements present real challenges that must be addressed through thoughtful system design and management.

For growers prepared to meet these demands, pacu can play a powerful role in a productive, sustainable aquaponic ecosystem—providing both abundant plant nutrients and a high-quality source of fish protein.

Back to blog